I know the title of the topic is a bit misleading so I’ll add more information. When I start the server, it starts under my local IP and not my Internet IP. The other person who wants to join the server can’t join unless the server is broadcasted over the Internet and not just locally.
Basically, it seems like the server is hosting on the network from my router, but not from the Internet itself. If we were on the same router I could do it that way, but we aren’t. I’m guessing this is what port forwarding is for?